Could Copart Be the Next Classic Buffett Investment?

The Long-Term Track Record

Since its IPO in 1994, Copart has returned approximately 19,092% to shareholders — one of the most remarkable compounding records of any publicly traded company over that span. That number is not a typo. An investor who put $10,000 into Copart at the IPO and held through every pullback, every recession, and every moment of doubt along the way would have over $1.9 million today. That kind of long-term performance puts Copart in rare company — alongside the businesses Buffett has described as the ones he most regrets not finding earlier.

And yet right now, the stock is down approximately 40% from its all-time highs, down 25% year to date, and negative over a five-year basis. For long-term investors who have been watching Copart from a distance waiting for a better entry point, this is the moment worth paying close attention to. The question is whether the selloff reflects a permanent change in the business or a temporary convergence of headwinds that the market is overweighting.

What Copart Actually Does

Copart operates online vehicle auctions, primarily for insurance companies that need to liquidate totaled cars quickly and efficiently. When an insurer declares a vehicle a total loss after an accident, it needs to recover as much value as possible from that car. Copart runs the auction — and crucially, it owns or controls the physical storage yards where those vehicles sit until they are sold. Buyers from around the world bid through Copart's platform, global competition drives prices up, the insurance company recovers more value, and Copart collects a fee on both sides of the transaction.

The physical infrastructure is the key to understanding why this business is so defensible. Copart owns or operates over 200 storage facilities across North America and internationally. That real estate footprint took decades to build and cannot be replicated by writing a check. A competitor wanting to challenge Copart would need to acquire land in hundreds of markets, obtain permits, build out the yards, and then somehow convince insurance companies — who already have a relationship with a platform that generates superior outcomes through global buyer reach — to switch. The moat is structural and it compounds over time as the yard network grows and the global buyer base deepens.

What Gives Copart Staying Power

The business sits directly in the path of several powerful secular tailwinds that make it more valuable with each passing year. Modern vehicles are dramatically more expensive to repair than older ones — advanced driver assistance systems, cameras, sensors, and embedded electronics mean a collision that once cost $3,000 to fix now costs $10,000 or more. As repair costs rise, more vehicles cross the total loss threshold, which means more volume flowing through Copart's platform. This is a structural dynamic driven by vehicle technology, not by economic cycles.

International expansion adds a second growth layer. Copart has been building its presence in Europe, the Middle East, and other markets where salvage auction infrastructure is far less developed than in the US. Every new geography it enters has the same fundamental dynamic: insurers need an efficient liquidation solution, and Copart's global buyer network generates better outcomes than any local alternative. The international runway is measured in decades. Finally, the ROIC averaging 18.66% over the past decade tells you this is a business that consistently earns exceptional returns on the capital it deploys — exactly the kind of financial fingerprint Buffett and Munger have spent their careers looking for.

Current Concerns

The selloff is not without a reason. Insurance companies have been under meaningful pressure — elevated claims frequency, rising repair costs, and a difficult underwriting environment have pushed some insurers to tighten standards and hold vehicles longer before declaring total losses. If insurers total fewer vehicles as a percentage of claims, Copart's volume growth slows. That is a real near-term headwind and the market is pricing it seriously. Revenue growth has decelerated significantly — just 1% over the past year compared to 13% over five years and 14% over ten — which is the most visible sign of the current pressure. There are also broader macro concerns: if consumer spending tightens and auto accident frequency declines, total loss volume softens alongside it. None of these concerns are permanent threats to the business model. They are cyclical pressures on a structural compounder. But they are real enough to explain why the stock is where it is.

Stock Analyzer: CPRT

Running the stock analyzer with revenue growth assumptions of 3%, 6%, and 9%, profit margins of 30%, 32.5%, and 35%, free cash flow margins of 25%, 28%, and 31%, and a PE of 14 to 22, the fair value range comes out at a low of $21.85, a middle of $34.33, and a high of $53.39 on an earnings basis — and a low of $21.00, a middle of $32.70, and a high of $50.34 on a discounted cash flow basis, against a current price of $29.24. At the current price the stock is sitting between the mid and high scenario, implying a current price return of 10.49% at the middle and 16.29% at the high. This is not a stock screaming at a massive discount to fair value on conservative assumptions — but for a business with Copart's moat quality, long-term compounding record, and structural growth drivers, trading near the middle fair value scenario during a period of cyclical pressure is historically the kind of entry point that long-term investors have been rewarded for taking seriously.

Here’s the question I want you to answer to tag me with in the community or in the comments: Do you think Buffett would be a buyer of Copart and at what price? As always, I hope you enjoyed the read.

Disclaimer
Everything Money is Not an Investment Advisor: Everything Money (including Paul, Mo, and Any other person including, but not limited to, other staff members, guests, personalities, etc.) is not an investment adviser, and it is not registered as such with the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission or any other state or federal authority under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 or any other law. The investments and strategies discussed in Everything Money’s YouTube videos and on Everythingmoney.com are not and should not be considered investment advice and may not be suitable for you. They do not take into account your particular investment objectives, financial situation, needs, or personal circumstances and are not intended to be specific to you. Before acting on any investment or strategy discussed, you should always do your own research and make your own independent decision about whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances. You should also consider seeking advice from your own legal, financial, tax, accounting, or investment advisers. Everything Money does not provide such advice.

READ THE FULL DISCLAIMER HERE: https://everythingmoney.com/disclaimer